Homepage > The Compositional Style of C.P.E. Bach > Sturm und Drang > Sturm und Drang and Expressionism

This site introduces unknown Emanuel Bach (C. P. E. Bach).

Sturm und Drang and Expressionism

Asked ChatGPT4o: "What is the relationship between Sturm und Drang and Expressionism?"

Sturm und Drang and Expressionism belong to different periods and contexts, yet they share several commonalities, revealing an interesting connection between the two movements when compared.

1. Background and Characteristics of Sturm und Drang

• Era and Location

  • Developed in late 18th-century Germany (circa 1760–1780), mainly in literature and music.
  • Emerged as a reaction against the Enlightenment, emphasizing emotions and personal inner impulses over reason.

• Characteristics

  • Intense emotional expression, irregular forms, and a strong focus on nature and fate.
  • Key literary figures include Goethe (*The Sorrows of Young Werther*) and Schiller.
  • In music, composers like Haydn, Mozart, and Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach were influenced by Sturm und Drang.
  • Features include the use of dissonance, sudden dynamic shifts, and frequent use of minor keys.

2. Background and Characteristics of Expressionism

• Era and Location

  • Flourished in early 20th-century Germany and Austria, spanning visual arts, literature, and music.
  • Rooted in societal instability and the looming crisis before and after World War I, it pursued the expression of inner human emotions and extreme feelings.

• Characteristics

  • Depiction of inner turmoil, anxiety, and extreme emotions.
  • Musically led by Schoenberg, Berg, and Webern, marked by dissonance and the breakdown of tonality.
  • In visual arts, Edvard Munch (*The Scream*) and Kandinsky are prominent figures.

3. Commonalities

• Emphasis on Emotion

  • Both movements prioritize emotion over reason, placing inner impulses and intense feelings at the core of artistic expression.
  • Sturm und Drang links intense emotions with the forces of nature and fate.
  • Expressionism focuses on inner human anxiety and isolation.

• Freedom of Form

  • Sturm und Drang broke traditional literary and musical forms, pursuing unpredictable developments.
  • Expressionism similarly embraced free expression, unrestricted by form or tonality.

• Depiction of Anxiety and Conflict

  • Sturm und Drang expressed conflict with nature and fate, centering instability in its works.
  • Expressionism explored themes of societal tension, human relationships, and internal conflict.

4. Differences

• Historical Context

  • Sturm und Drang emerged in the late 18th century as a reaction to the Enlightenment and Classicism, expressing early modern individualism.
  • Expressionism arose in the early 20th century, influenced by societal crises, war, and technological advancements.

• Direction of Emotion

  • Sturm und Drang often features elevated emotions with a heroic spirit challenging nature and fate.
  • Expressionism emphasizes inward emotions, highlighting despair, anxiety, and isolation.

• Technological Development and Impact

  • Sturm und Drang deepened emotional expression within tonal frameworks.
  • Expressionism transcended tonality, employing atonality and new harmonic methods to push expressive boundaries.

5. Relationship and Influence

Sturm und Drang laid the foundation for Romantic music and literature by emphasizing emotional expression. This innovation was inherited through Romanticism and Symbolism, ultimately influencing early 20th-century Expressionism.

In music, the emotional intensity of Sturm und Drang can be seen as a precursor to the extreme emotional expression and formal freedom of Expressionism. However, while Sturm und Drang embodies emotional elevation and heroism, Expressionism delves into extreme emotional depth and anguish.

Conclusion: While Sturm und Drang and Expressionism share common ground in emotional emphasis and formal freedom, differences in emotional character, historical context, and artistic approach distinguish them. Nevertheless, Sturm und Drangʼs pioneering pursuit of emotional expression can be viewed as one of the foundations of Expressionism.

Asked ChatGPT4o: "Were there any Romantic composers influenced by Sturm und Drang?"

Many Romantic composers were influenced by Sturm und Drang. This late 18th-century movement, characterized by heightened emotional expression, drama, frequent use of minor keys, and irregular rhythms, significantly impacted the Romantic eraʼs deepening emotional expression. Below are notable Romantic composers influenced by Sturm und Drang and examples of their works.

1. Ludwig van Beethoven

• Influence from Sturm und Drang
  Beethoven inherited and further developed the movementʼs emotional intensity and dramatic tension. His frequent use of minor keys and dynamic contrasts reflects this influence.
• Representative Works
  • Symphony No. 5 "Fate" (dramatic minor-key development)
  • Piano Sonata No. 8 "Pathétique"
  • String Quartet No. 11 "Serioso"

2. Franz Schubert

• Influence from Sturm und Drang
  Schubert inherited Sturm und Drangʼs dramatic expression while adding lyricism. His songs often emphasize emotional shifts and tension.
• Representative Works
  • Song cycle *Winterreise* (inner turmoil and emotional fluctuation)
  • Symphony No. 8 "Unfinished" (tense and lyrical in minor)

3. Felix Mendelssohn

• Influence from Sturm und Drang
  Mendelssohn incorporated Sturm und Drang elements with Romantic clarity, evident in his dramatic minor-key usage.
• Representative Works
  • Octet for Strings (dramatic tension and energy)
  • Overture *The Hebrides* (natural imagery and drama)

4. Robert Schumann

• Influence from Sturm und Drang
  Schumann deepened emotional conflict, adding poetic and dreamy elements.
• Representative Works
  • *Fantasiestücke* (diverse emotions and drama)
  • Symphony No. 4 (intense emotional contrast)

5. Johannes Brahms

• Influence from Sturm und Drang
  Brahms expanded the movementʼs emotional depth and dramatic minor-key style within Romantic idioms.
• Representative Works
  • Symphony No. 1 (tense and grand drama)
  • Piano Quintet (dramatic development and internal conflict)

Summary

The emotional intensity and drama of Sturm und Drang became central to Romantic music. Through composers like Beethoven and Schubert, these elements evolved, deepening the expression of inner emotion and natural imagery across the Romantic era.

Site search by Google

Parents

< Sturm und Drang