Top > Musical Styles and Theory > Sonata Form > Sonata Form of J.C. Bach

This site introduces unknown Emanuel Bach (C. P. E. Bach). This English version was translated from Japanese one by ChatGPT.

Sonata Form of Christian Bach

Characteristics of Christian Bachʼs Sonata Form

1. Double Exposition Structure
In Christian Bachʼs concertos, the “double exposition form,” where the exposition is presented twice, is common. Initially, the orchestra plays the exposition, followed by the solo instrument, which complements the orchestra and further develops the themes with more brilliance.

2. Clear Contrast of Themes
In the exposition, the first theme (tonic key) and the second theme (dominant key) are clearly contrasted. This allows the audience to intuitively understand the tonal changes and musical flow.

3. Conciseness of the Development Section
Christian Bachʼs development sections avoid contrapuntal complexity, instead varying and modulating the themes and motifs concisely. This maintains the musicʼs light and approachable character.

4. Tonal Unity in the Recapitulation
In the recapitulation, both the first and second themes are presented in the tonic key, establishing the tonal stability typical of the Classical period. This creates a sense of unity throughout the movement.

Utilization of Sonata Form in Concertos

1. Piano Concerto No. 6 in B-flat Major, Op. 7, No. 6
This concerto employs the double exposition form, with attractive free ornamentation and improvisational elements in the solo sections. The contrast of themes is clear, and the sense of tonality is rich.

2. Harpsichord Concerto in D Major, Op. 13, No. 2
The transition of keys and the precise recapitulation of themes highlight the structural beauty of the sonata form. The dialogic relationship between the solo instrument and the orchestra is emphasized.

3. Piano Concerto in E Major, Op. 7, No. 5
Characterized by a light and bright galant style, the conciseness of the sonata form supports the clear impression of this work.

Influence of Christian Bach

Christian Bachʼs sonata form laid the foundation for the Classical concerto and greatly influenced the young Mozart. His music, while eschewing complexity, possessed a refined formal beauty, enhancing its appeal as music beloved by audiences. As a result, the sonata form became established as the standard structure in concertos.

Conclusion

Christian Bachʼs sonata form, with its tonal contrasts, thematic clarity, and structural unity, played an indispensable role in the development of the Classical concerto. His concise and approachable music significantly influenced later generations and contributed to the dissemination and development of the sonata form.

...

I asked ChatGPT4o: "It is said that Christian Bach used a method in the first movement of keyboard concertos where the orchestra first presents the first and second themes in the same key, and then the keyboard instrument presents the second theme a fifth above the first theme. Did Mozart, influenced by Christian Bach, also use such a method?"

Johann Christian Bach (J. C. Bach) used a form in the first movement of keyboard concertos where the orchestra presents the first and second themes in the same key, and then the keyboard instrument presents the second theme a fifth above the first theme. This structure later influenced Mozart, and similar methods can be seen in his concertos.

Influence of Johann Christian Bach

1. Structural Characteristics:

   • The first movement of J. C. Bachʼs concertos often follows a structure like this:
     • Orchestral Exposition: The first and second themes are presented in the same key.
     • Solo Exposition: The keyboard instrument enters, reproduces the first theme, and presents the second theme a fifth above the first theme.

2. Musical Influence:

   • Mozart met J. C. Bach in London when he was young and was deeply influenced by his music. J. C. Bachʼs concerto form and melodic style influenced Mozartʼs compositional techniques.

Mozartʼs Concertos

1. Adoption of the Form:

   • In Mozartʼs piano concertos, the influence of J. C. Bachʼs form can be seen. Particularly, the following structure is sometimes used:
     • Orchestral Exposition: The orchestra presents the first and second themes in the same key.
     • Solo Exposition: The piano reproduces the first theme and presents the second theme a fifth above the first theme.

2. Specific Examples:

   • This method can be seen in many of Mozartʼs concertos, such as Piano Concerto No. 9 (K. 271 “Jeunehomme”), No. 20 (K. 466), and No. 21 (K. 467). These concertos feature a clever combination of dialogue between the orchestra and piano, reflecting J. C. Bachʼs influence.

Conclusion

The form used by Johann Christian Bach in keyboard concertos influenced Mozart, and similar methods can be seen in his concertos. Particularly, the form where the orchestra presents the first and second themes in the same key, and the keyboard instrument presents the second theme a fifth above the first theme, is an important element in the structure of Mozartʼs concertos.

I asked ChatGPT4o: “What about Haydnʼs concertos?”

In Joseph Haydnʼs concertos, the influence of Johann Christian Bach (J. C. Bach) can also be seen. Particularly, regarding the form and method of presenting themes in the first movement of concertos, there are some commonalities, but Haydn also incorporated his own methods. Below is an explanation of Haydnʼs concertos.

Form in Haydnʼs Concertos

1. Orchestral Exposition and Solo Exposition:

   • In Haydnʼs concertos, it is common for the orchestra to present the themes in the first movement, followed by the solo instrument taking over.
   • For example, the orchestra presents the first and second themes, and then the solo instrument appears to reproduce these themes.

2. Modulation:

   • In Haydnʼs concertos, the change of key after the solo instrument appears plays an important role. The solo instrument may present the second theme in a different key from the orchestraʼs presentation.
   • However, the method of clearly presenting the second theme a fifth above the first theme, as seen in J. C. Bachʼs concertos, is not consistently used in Haydnʼs concertos.

Specific Examples

1. Cello Concerto No. 1 in C Major, Hob. VIIb/1:

   • In the first movement, the orchestra presents the first theme, followed by the solo cello reproducing the first theme. The second theme is presented in a different key, but it differs slightly from J. C. Bachʼs form.

2. Trumpet Concerto in E-flat Major, Hob. VIIe/1:

   • In the first movement, the orchestra presents the first and second themes, followed by the solo trumpet developing these themes. Modulation is also seen, but Haydn incorporates his own methods while being influenced by J. C. Bach.

Haydnʼs Uniqueness

1. Development and Expansion of Themes:

   • Haydn had his own methods for developing and expanding themes. He often varied themes and reproduced them in various forms, enriching the overall structure of the movement.

2. Elements of Humor and Surprise:

   • Haydn enjoyed incorporating elements of humor and surprise into his compositions. This provided his concertos with fresh and unpredictable developments for the audience.

Summary

While it is certain that Johann Christian Bachʼs form influenced Mozart and Haydn, Haydn also incorporated his own methods, and his concertos have their own unique characteristics. Although the form of the orchestral exposition and solo exposition is common, regarding modulation and the method of presenting themes, Haydn often takes a different approach from J. C. Bach. Haydnʼs concertos are characterized by his creativity and unique style.

I asked ChatGPT4o: "In cello concertos, in what key is the second theme presented?"

Regarding the key of the second theme in Joseph Haydnʼs cello concertos, particularly using “Cello Concerto No. 1 in C Major, Hob. VIIb/1” as an example, the following explanation is provided.

Cello Concerto No. 1 in C Major, Hob. VIIb/1

1. Structure of the First Movement:

   • The first movement is structured in sonata form (or sonata-allegro form), which generally has the following structure:
     • Orchestral Exposition: The orchestra presents the first and second themes.
     • Solo Exposition: The solo cello enters and reproduces the themes presented by the orchestra.
     • Development: The themes are developed and modulate through various keys.
     • Recapitulation: The themes are reproduced, returning to the original key.

2. Key Development:

   • Orchestral Exposition:

     • The first theme is presented in C major (tonic key).
     • The second theme is traditionally presented in the dominant key, G major.

   • Solo Exposition:

     • The solo cello enters and reproduces the first theme in C major.
     • The second theme is again presented in G major, but with the addition of the solo instrument, new nuances are introduced.

Cello Concerto No. 2 in D Major, Hob. VIIb/2

Similarly, in Haydnʼs “Cello Concerto No. 2 in D Major, Hob. VIIb/2,” the development of keys according to sonata form is observed.

1. Structure of the First Movement:
   • The first theme is presented in D major (tonic key).
   • The second theme is presented in the dominant key, A major.

Summary

In Haydnʼs cello concertos, the key of the second theme is generally presented in the dominant key according to the conventions of sonata form. Specifically, in Cello Concerto No. 1 in C Major, the first theme is presented in C major, and the second theme is presented in G major. In Cello Concerto No. 2 in D Major, the first theme is presented in D major, and the second theme is presented in A major.

Thus, Haydnʼs cello concertos are based on the sonata form of the Classical period, and the key of the second theme is developed according to that form.

I asked ChatGPT4o: "It is thought that Sanmartiniʼs sonata form was inherited by Christian Bach, but what are the differences between the sonata forms of the two?"

The view that Sanmartiniʼs sonata form was inherited by Johann Christian Bach is musically intriguing. There are several commonalities and differences between their sonata forms. Below is a summary of the characteristics and differences of each form.

Commonalities

1. Three-Part Structure (Exposition, Development, Recapitulation):

   • Both adopt the basic structure of sonata form, consisting of an exposition, development, and recapitulation.

2. Two Themes (Theme A and Theme B):

   • In the exposition, they adopt the form of presenting Theme A in the tonic key and Theme B in the dominant key.

3. Motivic Development in the Development Section:

   • They use the method of developing the themes presented in the exposition in the development section, creating a dramatic musical development.

Differences

1. Complexity and Sophistication of Form:

   • Sanmartini: Sanmartiniʼs sonata form is at an early stage and has a relatively simple and direct structure. The development section is short, and the motivic development is often basic.
   • Christian Bach: Johann Christian Bachʼs sonata form is more complex and sophisticated than Sanmartiniʼs. The development section is longer, with diverse motivic development and modulation. He employs ornamentation and variation techniques to create more expressive music.

2. Handling of Melody:

   • Sanmartini: Sanmartiniʼs melodies are characterized by simplicity and a singing quality. His music is clear, with a well-defined structure.
   • Christian Bach: Christian Bachʼs melodies are more ornamental and complex. He frequently uses ornamentation and subtle rhythmic changes to give the melody a multi-layered nuance.

3. Handling of Harmony and Tonality:

   • Sanmartini: Sanmartiniʼs harmony is relatively simple, with a clear relationship between the tonic and dominant keys. Some modulation is seen in the development section, but overall it is tonally stable.
   • Christian Bach: Christian Bach uses bolder modulations and complex harmonic progressions. His development sections explore many tonalities, showing musical adventure.

4. Rhythm and Dynamics:

   • Sanmartini: Sanmartiniʼs rhythm is regular, and changes in dynamics are modest.
   • Christian Bach: Christian Bach frequently uses changes in rhythm and contrasts in dynamics, bringing dramatic effects to the music.

Summary

While there are basic structural commonalities between the sonata forms of Sanmartini and Johann Christian Bach, there are notable differences in complexity and sophistication, handling of melody and harmony, and use of rhythm and dynamics. Christian Bach, while building on Sanmartiniʼs form, developed his own musical style and established a more expressive and complex sonata form.

I asked ChatGPT4o: "You wrote, ʼThe view that Sanmartiniʼs sonata form was inherited by Johann Christian Bach is musically intriguing,ʼ but does this mean that this view is not a settled theory?"

The view that "Sanmartiniʼs sonata form was inherited by Johann Christian Bach" is supported to some extent in music history, but it cannot be said to be a settled theory. Research in music history is constantly evolving, and specific views may change over time. Below is an explanation of this view and why it cannot be said to be a settled theory.

Reasons

1. Limitations of Evidence:

   • There are few clear historical documents or evidence proving a direct master-disciple or influence relationship between Sanmartini and Johann Christian Bach, making it difficult to draw definitive conclusions about their musical relationship.

2. Diverse Influences:

   • 18th-century musicians were influenced by many different sources. While Sanmartiniʼs influence is conceivable, Johann Christian Bach may have also been influenced by other musicians and regional musical styles, making it difficult to identify a single source of influence.

3. Evolution of Music:

   • Sonata form itself evolved throughout the 18th century, making it difficult to clarify how individual composers adopted and developed this form. Many composers contributed to the development of sonata form, and their influence relationships are complex.

4. Progress of Research:

   • Research in music history is continuously progressing, and new materials and interpretations may emerge. This may lead to a reevaluation of existing views. New insights into the relationship between Sanmartini and Johann Christian Bach may be obtained through future research.

Summary

The view that "Sanmartiniʼs sonata form was inherited by Johann Christian Bach" is indeed musically intriguing and receives some support, but there are still parts where evidence and research are insufficient for it to be considered a settled theory. Therefore, while it is a strong view, it is necessary to consider other views as well.

Research in music history is multifaceted, and for a specific view to become a settled theory, extensive evidence and broad agreement among researchers are required.

I asked ChatGPT4o: "Are there other composers besides Sanmartini who influenced Christian Bach in establishing his sonata form?"

In establishing his sonata form, Johann Christian Bach was influenced by composers other than Sanmartini. His musical style is at the intersection of various elements and influences. Below are some of the major composers and musical elements that may have influenced Johann Christian Bach.

Composers and Musical Elements Influencing Him

1. His Father, Johann Sebastian Bach:

   • Johann Christian Bachʼs father, Johann Sebastian Bach, was a master of Baroque music, and his counterpoint and compositional techniques influenced Johann Christian. The musical education he received from his father in his youth laid the foundation.

2. Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach:

   • His brother, Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach, developed the “Empfindsamer Stil” characterized by emotional expression and free form. This style influenced Johann Christianʼs music and is reflected in the richness of expression in his sonata form.

3. Italian Composers (Especially Opera):

   • Johann Christian Bach studied music in Italy, where he was influenced by many Italian opera composers. His melodic lines and use of rhythm are strongly influenced by Italian opera. Notably, the influence of opera composers like Niccolò Jommelli and Giovanni Battista Pergolesi can be seen.

4. Mannheim School:

   • Johann Christian Bach was also influenced by the Mannheim School, known for dramatic changes in dynamics and technical innovations in orchestration. These elements are reflected in the dynamic expression and diversity of timbre in his symphonies and sonatas.

5. François-Joseph Gossec and Other French Composers:

   • Through his activities in Paris, he was also influenced by François-Joseph Gossec and other French composers. The elegant and refined French style was incorporated into his music.

6. George Frideric Handel:

   • During his time in London, he was also influenced by Handel. Handelʼs style in opera and oratorio helped add dramatic elements to Johann Christianʼs works.

Summary

In establishing his sonata form, Johann Christian Bach was influenced by many composers and musical elements besides Sanmartini. This made his music diverse, with a unique style that fused the styles of various regions and eras. Johann Christian Bachʼs works, as music from the transition period from Baroque to Classical, reflect diverse influences and form a unique style.

I asked ChatGPT4o: "Isnʼt what Christian Bach learned from the ʼinfluential composersʼ mentioned above something other than sonata form?"

Thank you for your observation. What Johann Christian Bach learned from the “influential composers” mentioned above extends beyond sonata form to a wide range of musical elements. However, there are many elements that contributed to the development of his sonata form through these influences. Below is a detailed explanation of the specific elements he learned and how they influenced his sonata form.

1. Johann Sebastian Bach

• Learned Elements: Counterpoint, harmonic construction, formal rigor
• Influence on Sonata Form:
  • Johann Christian Bach learned the basics of counterpoint from his father. This influenced his handling of motifs and harmonic progressions in the development section.

2. Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach

• Learned Elements: Empfindsamer Stil, expressive melodies
• Influence on Sonata Form:
  • The emotional expression and free form are reflected in the handling of melody and changes in dynamics in his sonata form, making it more emotional and dramatic.

3. Italian Composers (Especially Opera)

• Learned Elements: Singing melodies, operatic dramatic elements
• Influence on Sonata Form:
  • The singing melodic lines and dramatic structure learned from Italian opera composers influenced the handling of themes in the exposition and recapitulation of his sonata form.

4. Mannheim School

• Learned Elements: Dramatic changes in dynamics, orchestral innovations
• Influence on Sonata Form:
  • The dramatic changes in dynamics and orchestral innovations are reflected in the musical development in the development section and the climax in the recapitulation of his sonata form.

5. François-Joseph Gossec and Other French Composers

• Learned Elements: Elegant and refined style
• Influence on Sonata Form:
  • The elegant and refined French style influenced the beauty and expressiveness of themes in his sonata form.

6. George Frideric Handel

• Learned Elements: Dramatic structure, oratorio-like elements
• Influence on Sonata Form:
  • Handelʼs dramatic structure and oratorio-like elements influenced the dramatic development and conclusion of his sonata form.

Summary

While Johann Christian Bach learned many musical elements beyond sonata form, these elements also contributed to the development of his sonata form. His sonata form was shaped by multiple influences, and the various musical techniques and styles he learned supported the richness and complexity of his musical expression.

I asked ChatGPT4o: "In what way did Christian Bach learn from the Mannheim School?"

There is little direct literature or evidence about the specific ways Johann Christian Bach learned from the Mannheim School, but it is thought that he was influenced in the following ways.

1. Musical Exchange and Travel

• Johann Christian Bachʼs Travels:
  • Johann Christian Bach traveled across Europe while engaging in musical activities. He was active in Italy and London, but he may have visited Mannheim and other German cities, where he could have interacted with musicians there.
• Exchange Among Musicians:
  • Musicians in 18th-century Europe frequently traveled and performed concerts and operas in various cities. During such opportunities, he could have directly listened to the music of the Mannheim School or obtained and studied their scores.

2. Scores and Publications

• Distribution of Scores:
  • In the 18th century, the publication and distribution of scores became popular, and the scores of symphonies and chamber music by composers of the Mannheim School spread throughout Europe. Johann Christian Bach may have accessed these scores to learn the style and techniques of the Mannheim School.

3. Specific Aspects of Influence

• Use of Dynamics:

  • The Mannheim School was characterized by sudden changes in dynamics (Mannheim Rocket and Mannheim Crescendo). Johann Christian Bach incorporated such changes in dynamics into his works, enhancing the dramatic effect of the music.

• Orchestral Innovations:

  • The Mannheim School played a pioneering role in orchestral innovations, particularly in the use of wind instruments and technical passages for strings. Johann Christian Bach reflected these techniques in his orchestration, pursuing more diverse timbres and effects.

• Formal Sophistication:

  • The symphonies and sonatas of the Mannheim School were formally sophisticated and had a clear structure. Johann Christian Bach learned this formal sophistication and designed the structure of sonata forms and symphonies more precisely.

Summary

The influence Johann Christian Bach received from the Mannheim School was not based on direct master-disciple relationships or literature but was mainly obtained through musical exchanges and the study of scores. His music reflects the dramatic use of dynamics, orchestral innovations, and formal sophistication characteristic of the Mannheim School, contributing to the development of his sonata form and symphonies.

I asked ChatGPT4o: "Were there other Italian composers using sonata form when Christian Bach was studying under Sanmartini?"

When Johann Christian Bach was studying under Sanmartini, there were other Italian composers using sonata form. In the mid-18th century in Italy, sonata form was gradually being established, and many composers were adopting this new form. Below are some of the major Italian composers who used sonata form.

Italian Composers Using Sonata Form

1. Niccolò Jommelli (1714-1774)

   • Characteristics: Jommelli is famous as an opera composer, but his symphonies and overtures also show the influence of sonata form. His works are characterized by dramatic elements and rich harmony.
   • Influence: Jommelliʼs dramatic operatic style influenced the expressiveness and dramatic development in sonata form.

2. Giovanni Battista Pergolesi (1710-1736)

   • Characteristics: Pergolesi left many works during his short life. His chamber music and sacred music show early characteristics of sonata form.
   • Influence: Pergolesiʼs melodic style and simple form contributed to the development of sonata form.

3. Luigi Boccherini (1743-1805)

   • Characteristics: Boccherini is famous as a composer of chamber music, having composed many string quartets and symphonies. His works use a clear sonata form.
   • Influence: Boccheriniʼs works played an important role in the development of Italian sonata form.

4. Leonardo Leo (1694-1744)

   • Characteristics: Leo was active from the late Baroque to the early Classical period, and his symphonies and instrumental works contain elements of sonata form.
   • Influence: Leoʼs music influenced the early structure and melodic development of sonata form.

5. Baldassare Galuppi (1706-1785)

   • Characteristics: Galuppi left many operas and chamber music works, and his works also show the influence of sonata form.
   • Influence: Galuppiʼs music contributed to the development of sonata form, particularly in melodic development and formal clarity.

Summary

When Johann Christian Bach was studying under Sanmartini, many composers in Italy were adopting sonata form. These composers played important roles in the development of sonata form and influenced Bachʼs music. Particularly in the handling of melody, construction of form, and introduction of dramatic elements, Bachʼs sonata form is thought to have been influenced by these composers.

I asked ChatGPT4o: "Was Boccherini already composing when Christian Bach was studying under Sanmartini?"

When Johann Christian Bach was studying under Sanmartini, Luigi Boccherini was still young and had not yet begun composing in earnest.

Timeline

1. Johann Christian Bach

   • Birth Year: 1735
   • Period of Studying under Sanmartini: 1754 to 1762 (while in Italy)

2. Luigi Boccherini

   • Birth Year: 1743
   • Period of Beginning Compositional Activity: 1760s

Details

• Johann Christian Bach moved to Italy in 1754 and studied under Sanmartini. During this period, he was mainly active in Milan, composing church music and operas. What he learned in Italy greatly influenced his later activities in London.

• Luigi Boccherini was born in 1743 and received musical education from a young age. He began composing in earnest in the 1760s, and at that time, he was still building his career as a performer across Europe. Boccherini first gained attention with a collection of string quartets (Op. 2) published in Paris in 1761.

Summary

During the period when Johann Christian Bach was studying under Sanmartini, Luigi Boccherini was still in his early years, transitioning from childhood to youth, and had not yet begun his activities as a composer in earnest. Therefore, the sonata form and musical influences Bach learned in Italy were mainly from Sanmartini and other contemporary Italian composers. Boccheriniʼs influence would come after Bach began his activities in London.

Site search by Google

Upper< Lower> items

< Sonata Form
> The Completion of Sonata Form by Haydn