Top >
The Compositional Style of C.P.E. Bach >
Revisions of C.P.E. Bachʼs Works >
Revision Strategy of C. P. E. Bachʼs Works
This site introduces unknown composer Emanuel Bach (C. P. E. Bach).
This English version was translated from Japanese one by ChatGPT.
Revision Strategy of C. P. E. Bachʼs Works
Asked ChatGPT4o: “C. P. E. Bach frequently revised his own compositions. It seems that revising a work could help boost sheet music sales and also act as a countermeasure against piracy—was that actually his intention?”
Yes, behind Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach’s frequent revisions of his works were not only musical and performative motivations, but also strategic and commercial intentions related to publishing. Below are several reasons, categorized and explained.
🎼 1. Musical and Performative Reasons
-
Adaptation to changes in performers and instruments: During the transition from the clavichord to the fortepiano, many pieces were revised to suit the characteristics of new keyboard instruments (e.g., early sonatas restructured on a larger scale).
-
Evolution of style: From Baroque techniques to the “Empfindsamer Stil” (sensitive style), he revised compositions to align with his expressive intentions and changing tastes of the time.
-
Requirements from concerts and courts: Revisions were sometimes made to fit particular performance contexts or the requests of clients (royalty, nobility, publishers).
💰 2. Strategies for Publication and Sales
-
Reselling old works as “new”: By publishing revised versions, he could present similar content as new compositions, effectively increasing the number of publications.
-
Repositioning as a new edition: Especially in collections like Clavierstücke für Kenner und Liebhaber (Wq 55–59, Wq 61), older works were refreshed and included in series to appeal to new audiences.
-
Maintaining market freshness: By regularly revising and reissuing works, he maintained the image of being a “currently active composer,” preserving his market value.
🛡 3. Countermeasures Against Piracy and Unauthorized Copies
-
Reducing confusion from variant editions: By himself releasing alternate versions of the same piece, he made it harder to control or validate unauthorized handwritten or printed copies (to the extent that it became unclear which version was the “authentic” one).
-
Legitimizing autographs and official publications: By promoting the idea that “the latest revision = the official version,” he increased his own copyright-like authority over his music among audiences and performers.
📚 Examples for Reference
-
Wq 55–59 (Kenner und Liebhaber): These collections contain numerous revised works, some with altered structure, texture, or key.
-
Flute Concerto Wq 22 is a reworking of the Harpsichord Concerto Wq 14 — rather, the Harpsichord Concerto Wq 22 is a reworking of the Flute Concerto Wq 22-1, showing how materials were reused depending on the medium and audience.
📝 Conclusion
C. P. E. Bach’s practice of revising his works was not merely an act of “artistic growth” or “deepening of expression,” but also a strategic creative activity adapted to the realities of the music business at the time (responding to customer needs, competing in the publishing market, protecting his works). It could be likened to today’s concepts of “version upgrades” or “remastered re-releases.”