Unpublished Keyboard Concertos by C.P.E. Bach

I asked ChatGPT4o: “Are there any of Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach’s keyboard concertos that he did not publish during his lifetime?”

Several of Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach’s keyboard concertos were not published during his lifetime. Although he selectively published some of his keyboard concertos, not all of them saw publication. Many of his concertos, classified under Wq numbers, remained in manuscript form during his life and were only published posthumously by others.

C.P.E. Bach composed numerous works, and some concertos were kept in his possession, possibly intended for personal performances or educational purposes. Later, musicologists and publishers rediscovered these works, leading to their publication and recording.

For example, his keyboard concertos Wq. 3 and Wq. 10 are among those he did not publish.

I asked ChatGPT4o: “What distinguishes the concertos C.P.E. Bach published from those he did not?”

There are several factors that likely influenced C.P.E. Bach’s decision on which keyboard concertos to publish and which to withhold. The differences can be attributed to the following aspects:

1. Differences in Period and Style

His early keyboard concertos (e.g., Wq. 1–Wq. 6) were composed during the transitional period from the Baroque to the Classical era and exhibit Baroque influences. These early works were less likely to be published compared to his later, more refined and expressive compositions. His later works, which Bach deemed more mature and stylistically sophisticated, were more often selected for publication.
The published concertos typically had clearer forms and more polished structures, whereas the unpublished ones often contained experimental or unique stylistic elements.

2. Purpose and Demand

Bach’s published works were often intended for public performances or educational use and were popular among musicians in cultural centers like Berlin and Hamburg.
In contrast, some unpublished concertos may have been composed for specific private occasions or personal use in concerts, and they might not have appealed to the broader public or been considered commercially viable at the time.

3. Commercial Considerations

Publishing music was a costly and labor-intensive process, posing financial risks. C.P.E. Bach may have carefully chosen which concertos to publish, possibly avoiding those he believed would not sell well.
The published works were often in popular forms, aligning with contemporary tastes, whereas unpublished pieces might not have been seen as marketable.

4. Personal Preference and Evaluation

Some unpublished concertos might not have satisfied Bach’s own high standards. He was known for being self-critical and may have felt certain pieces were unworthy of publication.
The works he chose to publish were likely those he felt were his most complete and appealing to a wide audience.

5. Manuscript Availability

Some concertos that remained unpublished during his lifetime were discovered later in manuscript form and published posthumously. This suggests that certain works were intended more for private use rather than public dissemination.

These factors collectively influenced which of Bach’s concertos were published during his lifetime and which remained unpublished.

I asked ChatGPT4o: “Was there a significant delay between composing and publishing C.P.E. Bach’s concertos?”

Indeed, there were cases where significant time elapsed between the composition and publication of C.P.E. Bach’s keyboard concertos. Several factors contributed to this delay:

1. Composition to Publication Timeline

Many of Bach’s concertos were composed during his service in Berlin (1740–1768) but were not published until his later years in Hamburg (1768 onward). For instance, the Wq. 43 concertos were composed around 1767 but published in the 1770s after his move to Hamburg.

2. Professional Circumstances

While serving at the Berlin court, Bach had limited time for managing publications. It was only after relocating to Hamburg that he gained more freedom to focus on composing and publishing his works.

3. Economic Constraints

Publishing music was expensive, requiring significant financial investment. Bach may have delayed publishing certain works due to economic risks or uncertain demand.

4. Artistic Judgment

Bach may have waited to publish only those works he deemed fully polished. Some concertos intended for personal use might not have been prioritized for publication.

5. Posthumous Publications

Several of Bach’s concertos, such as Wq. 3 and Wq. 4, remained unpublished during his lifetime and were only brought to light by later musicologists.

I asked ChatGPT4o: “While C.P.E. Bach’s solo keyboard works were often financially successful, were his concertos profitable as well?”

C.P.E. Bach’s solo keyboard works were indeed commercially successful, often turning a profit. However, the same cannot be confidently said for his keyboard concertos. Several factors may have contributed to the relatively limited commercial success of his concertos:

1. Market Demand

Unlike solo keyboard pieces, concertos required orchestral accompaniment, limiting their appeal to a smaller audience of professional musicians and ensembles. Solo pieces, by contrast, were more accessible to amateur musicians and widely used in domestic music-making.

2. Higher Production Costs

Publishing a concerto involved printing multiple orchestral parts, making the process more expensive than publishing solo works. This higher initial investment made concertos riskier ventures commercially.

3. Limited Audience

Solo keyboard works appealed to a broad market, including amateurs and private players, whereas concertos catered mainly to professionals and public concert settings, resulting in limited demand.

4. Publishing Strategy

Bach may have been more selective with concerto publications, focusing on works he believed would succeed commercially. His solo works, being more marketable, were more aggressively published.

Overall, while Bach’s solo keyboard works were financially successful, his concertos likely did not achieve the same level of commercial success, possibly due to limited demand and higher production costs.

Site search by Google

Parents

< ★C.P.E. Bachʼs Musical Works
< The Publishing Activities of C.P.E. Bach